This thread has brought up the question as to whether adding reverb to a wet sample set might be effective. So, I have given it a try. Recently I uploaded the Jan Zwart piece, “Alle Roem Is Uitgesloten,” to contrebombarde. That upload used only the natural reverb that comes with the Caen CC samples. Today I uploaded the same piece, but with 40% Lexicon reverb added. For what it’s worth, one can listen to each and judge the value of the added (Lexicon-type) reverb, in this case. It definitely makes the space seem larger.
As was mentioned on this thread, reverb might be added to get the sound to seem more like the listener is used to hearing (farther from the pipes, perhaps). I tried it hoping to come closer to the thrilling sound of the Hinsz organ. I sort-of succeeded I guess. I still have the sound of the big French Romantic organ, but the acoustic environment is greatly expanded (or perhaps one could say the listener is farther back from the organ).
The original version:
http://www.contrebombarde.com/concerthall/music/2252The reverb’ed version:
http://www.contrebombarde.com/concerthall/music/2295For those who are interested in how the reverb-added recording was accomplished:
The MIDI file of the piece is played on an XP 32-bit PC.
The PC MIDI output goes to the MIDI input on the Mac Pro.
The Caen organ is loaded on the Mac Pro and plays the MIDI information.
The audio optical-digital output of the Mac Pro goes to the coaxial-digital input on the Lexicon MPX-400. (I use an optical-to-coaxial converter from CablesToGo.)
The coaxial-digital output from the Lexicon goes to the coaxial-digital input on the Tascam US-144 audio interface back on the XP computer.
The music is then recorded on the PC using Sound Forge. The audio is digital all the way, including the added reverb.
Sound forge is then used to save the 24-bit, 48000 Hz file to disk,
And Sound Forge is then used to convert the file to 16-bit, 44100 Hz and then to an mp3 file so as to conform to contrebombarde requirements.
(Note: both the MPX-400 and the US-144 have been discontinued and replaced by newer units, though drivers are still available, fortunately for me.)
I set this whole thing up actually so I could add some clean reverb to dry sample sets when I feel the need to record them. Since I have invested mostly in dry sets for the multiple speaker set up, I need the help of a reverb of some sort when recording directly in the computer.
I have never gotten into the newer types of computer software reverbs as yet. They may well do a much better job than the Lexicon. Nevertheless, I think I will conclude that adding reverb to a wet set can be worth doing, under certain circumstances.
Leo Chris.